Special Order Ketolicious Cakes

 Introducing Keto Cake Delivery

If you are looking for keto cake delivery shipped to you, you’ve arrived at the right place! The newest addition to our special orders is our made-to-order Ketolicious Cakes. A keto birthday cake delivered is the perfect addition to your celebration – or any special occasion!

These  Ketolicious Bake Shop cakes are 8″, triple-layer cakes with your choice of cake and frosting. The cost of each cake is $65 plus shipping and handling.

Our delicious cakes are keto- and diabetes-friendly, gluten- and sugar-free. Made with only wholesome ingredients, this is your healthier version of a dessert with all the flavor and none of the guilt.

Each cake is made-to-order especially for you by Ketolicious Bake Shop.

Every effort will be made to accommodate your request. If we can accommodate your request, you will be emailed the total cost of your order (which is the price of the cake plus shipping and handling) along with a link to a password-protected page from which you will be able to finalize your order and process payment. If we cannot accommodate your request, we will notify you as soon as practical.

If you are interested in ordering, please complete the pre-order form and be sure to submit it

(56 customer reviews)

Note: Toppings may vary.

Immediately upon receipt, place the cake in the refrigerator for 7 to 10 days or freeze up to 6 months.

For the best flavor, leave out on the counter for 2 hours prior to serving.

Allergen Alert: Our cakes are made in a facility that uses eggs, nuts and dairy.

 Keto Cake Flavor and Frosting Choices

On the pre-order form, you can choose your cake flavor from carrot, chocolate, lemon or vanilla and also select your frosting from: cream cheese, chocolate, lemon, peanut butter or vanilla. You pair your favorite cake flavor with any of our decadently delicious frostings for the perfect combination!

Keto Cake Delivery and Shipment

Since Ketolicious Bake Shop values your business and is honored to be a small part of your celebration or special dinner, please call if you do not hear back from us within 48 hours after you submit your request. We would hate to disappoint you.

We ship to all 48 states. If you’re local to Califon, NJ, we can arrange pickup or delivery. Local delivery is generally limited to a 10-mile radius from Califon, NJ.  

Note: Your order is NOT confirmed until your payment has been processed successfully.

Shipping and handling will be calculated by customer service prior to you placing your order. If you proceed with your order, please be certain to choose the shipping carrier noted in your confirmation email when placing your order. 

56 reviews for 8" Triple Layer Cake

  1. Robert K.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew Jersey, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thanks Robert

  2. John W

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usTexas, United States

    Wow! The taste was wonderful & Keto friendly

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Im so glad you enjoyed the cake!!

  3. Stephanie C.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usPennsylvania, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you

  4. Tanya

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | nzNew Zealand

    My parents said the cake was absolutely delicious 🙂 Even my father, who isn’t Keto, couldn’t believe there was no sugar in it. When I get back to the States, I look forward to ordering one of these for myself!! Thank you again!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you so much Tanya! Im so glad even the non keto people enjoyed it. That’s a real compliment!!

  5. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usFlorida, United States

    All of the Keto people in our office loved the cake and thought it was a very nice treat to have. We would order from this bakery again!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you so much. Im so glad everyone enjoyed the cake!

  6. Samantha

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usMaryland, United States

  7. Maryann

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usVirginia, United States

    Cake was delicious!!!! I will definitely start ordering my bday cake from this business every year. I’m gluten free and not keto, but liked the taste of this cake better because I prefer nut flours and do not like refined sugar.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you Maryann. I’m so glad you enjoyed your birthday cake!

  8. Rebecca Burnside

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usCalifornia, United States

    Just incredible. If you are strict Keto, this bakery is one of a kind. They made a delicious peanut butter chocolate cake for a zoom wedding reception for a keto couple. JUST INCREDIBLE!! It made the happy couple feel so special to have a real keto cake. They are even freezing a large section to eat on their first anniversary.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      It was fun creating a cake for the newly weds! Thanks so much!!

  9. CaSondra M.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

  10. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usFlorida, United States

    Love the cake. A real treat for those of us on a restricted sugar and carb diet. Even those who aren’t

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you! Im so glad you enjoyed it!

  11. Linna

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usMassachusetts, United States

    What an amazing decadent chocolate cake that totally brought the festivity to the birthday celebration this year!! You would never ever guess this cake is keto, and the frosting was so rich and creamy it tasted like the inside of a Lindt truffle dipped in Nutella. It was amazing to be able to indulge in such a treat without any of the guilt or bad sugar crash! Also the cake was so satiating (prob bc of the fat bomb effect) we could only eat one piece a day so it lasted our family of 3 almost a whole week!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Im so happy to hear you enjoyed the cake and we were able to help you celebrate in style!!!

  12. Stan M.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usPennsylvania, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  13. Jurica

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usConnecticut, United States

    Delicious and perfectly sweet.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  14. Edward K.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usPennsylvania, United States

    This was a fantastic birthday cake!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  15. Heather C.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    The icing was good. The cake was extremely dry. For the price I was expecting more.

  16. Michelle Lee

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usOhio, United States

    SO GOOD! Everyone loved it, even our non-keto guests:)

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  17. Shyann H.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    Best Keto cake ever!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  18. Teresa T.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew Jersey, United States

    Absolutely delicious

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  19. Melissa Smith

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew Jersey, United States

    Omg !!! The cake was so good, Thanks my friends are still about it !!! Thanks again

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  20. Shyann H.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew York, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  21. Jaime W.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    This cake was fantastic, I’m so glad I ordered it! My husband absolutely loved it. He was so excited to have an actual cake for his birthday. It arrived right on time, well-protected and tasted amazing!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Jaime! So happy your husband enjoyed it.

  22. Amanda Brown

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  23. Carrie

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usVirginia, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Carrie!

  24. Kathie T.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usTexas, United States

    This cake was for my son’s birthday and we thoroughly enjoyed it. Half was eaten by all the kids the first nite. It was so rich that half a slice would suffice! Thank you so much for helping us celebrate this special day.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Kathie! SO happy you guys enjoyed it.

  25. Cindy V.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usPennsylvania, United States

    Thank you so much for my bday Cake, it was delicious people couldn’t believe it had no sugar ❤️❤️❤️

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Cindy!

  26. Anthony Cormier

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usMassachusetts, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  27. Mariah W.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usFlorida, United States

    Ordered a lemon cake with vanilla icing and a vanilla cake with chocolate icing as well. The lemon one was absolutely delicious but I was unfortunately not able to try the chocolate vanilla one as it was damaged during shipping.

  28. Teresa Austin

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usCalifornia, United States

    The cake arrived just in time and was not only delicious but lovely!! I have attempted to make Keto friendly cakes and nothing compares to yours! Well done!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  29. Monica Garza

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usMichigan, United States

    Delicious!! This cake was SO worth it!!! I got this for my girlfriend & she LOVED it! It got to me in Michigan in perfect time too!! I would recommend anyone who asks me for a keto cake!!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  30. Donna

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew York, United States

    Totally decadent cake that is not too sweet. All my friends loved it! (I got the vanilla cake with vanilla iceing). Can’t believe it’s keto!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  31. Teresa

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  32. Troy Bateman

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usIndiana, United States

    The cake was delicious.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Troy!

  33. David

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    Impossible to tell this cake is not made with sugar. The cream cheese icing was decadent and plentiful and the cake moist and delicious!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  34. Chris

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    Cake was so good – couldn’t tell that it was keto friendly it was that good!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you so much!

  35. Audrey F.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usMaryland, United States

    Wow! No need for any other cake! I love chocolate and this cake was delicious. I was so happy on my birthday with this cake. I started a keto diet and did not want to stray too far off of the diet plan. But I need my chocolate! It exceeded my expectations.
    My husband is not used to alternate diets and he loved it! I asked him if his father would like this cake or notice this is a healthier cake. My husband said if we don’t tell him, he would never notice. It is amazing that these cakes are diabetic friendly too!
    I feel so blessed that there are people like Siobhan who create beautiful things like Ketolicious cakes. Siobhan you made me so happy on my birthday and I didn’t need to skip a birthday cake! Thank you Siobhan!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you so much, Audrey. It’s hard enough as it is to try to stick to a diet so having some sweets in your life makes it that much better! We are so glad you enjoyed the cake!😊

  36. Tony

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  37. Marianne C.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew Jersey, United States

    Everyone who had a piece agreed it was delicious.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊

  38. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usPennsylvania, United States

    You make so many people in office happy 🙂

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!😊 Good for any office occasion!

  39. VALERIE G.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usFlorida, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you! 😊

  40. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usNew Jersey, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you! 😊

  41. JOAN P.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usCalifornia, United States

    This is my second cake ordered and the cake tastes yummy and goes beyond expectations. With the combo flavors of the frosting and different flavors of the cake offered, it will always be a delicious tasting cake no matter what flavor you chose. Thank you for making my celebrations happy and wonderful with your baking.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Joan, i am so grateful for your kind words. We try very hard to make sure your celebrations are special. Thank you again!😊

  42. Tara T.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usIndiana, United States

    The cake was absolutely delicious as always! Even the non keto enjoyed it!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Tara!

  43. Desiree P.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link

    My husband was thrilled to have a low
    Carb cake instead of a pudding for his birthday. The rest of the family guests didn’t even notice a difference and asked for seconds! Thanks for being awesome. 🙂

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Desiree!!

  44. Thomas R.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usPennsylvania, United States

    I will absolutely order again!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Thomas!

  45. Jonathan M.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usMississippi, United States

    Per my wife, ” The best dang keto cake shes ever had!!!” we will be ordering again

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Jonathan!

  46. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link

    The cake was delicious, but the decorations on the cake were as if a child made it. Honestly, it is extremely overpriced.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      I am so sorry you did not enjoy the decorations. The cakes are priced to reflect the high-quality ingredients, handmade cakes, and that every cake is made to order. Thanks.

  47. Erin Zavala

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usTexas, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  48. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link

    The cake writing arrived smushed by the dry ice that was packed with it. The frosting was too thick. I thought the cake would be more flavorful and decadent. It was too plain. Thanks for your effort!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Oh no! I am so sorry that this happened. Please contact our customer service line to fix this issue! E-Mail: Customerservice@ketoliciousllc.com

  49. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  50. Joseph R.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usArizona, United States

    Our first ever Keto Cake order. It was outstanding! I have shared this site with my friends.

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Joseph, thank you! We love getting the word out to all of those who want a healthier choice for dessert!

  51. Domenic C.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usRhode Island, United States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  52. Netta B.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usConnecticut, United States

    So good!!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Netta, Thank you!

  53. Randall H.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you!

  54. Ray Brackins

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usUnited States

    Cake was great thanks!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Ray- Thank you!

  55. Mariah W.

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usFlorida, United States

    Best cake ever! I got a carrot cake with cream cheese frosting and it was so delicious! Cake was wrapped super well and was decorated so cute! It arrived on time and safely. I requested a happy birthday message on mine and it was perfect. 🙂 Thank you so much!!

    • Siobhan Papantonis

      Thank you, Mariah! So glad you enjoyed.

  56. Anonymous

    Verified reviewVerified review - view originalExternal link | usCalifornia, United States

    Wonderful 🙂 I would definitely order again!

Add a review

Your email address will not be published.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This